The IntelForum Archives

61 Spies and the Middle East Peace Talks: A Response to WHTIAKER -- rank: 799

... definitions, whatever his original intent. On a the topic of POLLARD, Prof. WHITAKER wrote: "The argument that spying on behalf of ... wall. Turning to the post by Prof. D'AMATO on POLLARD, he asks concerning WEINBERGER's role: "But then what made ... elements in certain cases. YURCHENKO had redefected 3 weeks before POLLARD was sentenced after revealing many Soviet agents; WALKER and his ... Congress was investigating the mess. Not to be left out, POLLARD received his sentence after agreeing to tell all, but never ... the Israelis would never have worked for his release. Nevertheless, POLLARD, according to Time magazine, boasted before sentencing that "he ...

Poster's Name:	HBP
Poster's Email:	BkCollector at home.com
Message Date:	2000-07-27 22:46:00 UTC

62 BOOK ABOUT THE POLLARD CASE -- rank: 753

Recently someone inquired about books dealing with the Pollard case. Personally I have run across only one, published in1988. It is "Pollard-The Spy's Story-An American Dreyfus Affair ?" by Bernard R. Henderson. The author is or was Pollard's father-in -law. Much of the book consists of ...

Poster's Name:	Lehelfer at aol.com
Poster's Email:	Lehelfer at aol.com
Message Date:	2000-07-27 21:55:00 UTC

63 intelforum-Digest V2000 #431 -- rank: 209

... out there? I think not. As to the argument about Pollard - he got what he deserved. Few of us are privy ...

Poster's Name:	Tower, Peter A.
Poster's Email:	Peter.Tower at fiserv.com
Message Date:	2000-07-27 13:53:00 UTC

64 Spies and the Middle East Peace Talks -- rank: 665

... difference [between spying for allies and spying for enemies]. But Pollard, with his lawyer at his side, pled >guilty to the ... Thus, it made no difference who he was spying for. >Pollard was not aware of details of any U.S./Israel ... agreement. The US was not committed to provide the information Pollard >provided to Israel. I believe the US fulfilled all of ... and others for information that modifies my perspective on the Pollard situation; that's what a listserve can be especially good for. I recall that when Jonathan Pollard's father and sister were discussing with me as ...

Poster's Name:	Anthony D' Amato
Poster's Email:	a-damato at northwestern.edu
Message Date:	2000-07-27 13:49:00 UTC

65 Spies and the Middle East Peace Talks -- rank: 486

Re: Jonathan Pollard and who his sentence should be compared to or not ... comparison, more pertinent to Israel, which has been agitating for Pollard's release and moralizing about the alleged injustice of his ... allies, he blew the whistle publicly in the Sunday Times. Pollard was paid by Israel to spy on its good ally ... USA. Yet the same Israelis who whine so piteously about Pollard languishing in prison are still keeping Vannunu behind bars. One ...

Poster's Name:	Reg Whitaker
Poster's Email:	regwhit at yorku.ca
Message Date:	2000-07-27 10:42:00 UTC

66 Spies and the Middle East Peace Talks -- rank: 544

... understand why Prof D'Amato >sings the tune of the Pollard apologists. Walker is but one example. How >about Ronald Pelton ... intel information with Israel at the time, and didn't Pollard just tell Israel what we were committed to tell Israel ... singing off-key myself. >> Yes, there is a difference. But Pollard, with his lawyer at his side, pled guilty to the ... Thus, it made no difference who he was spying for. Pollard was not aware of details of any U.S./Israel ... agreement. The US was not committed to provide the information Pollard provided to Israel. I believe the US fulfilled all ...

Poster's Name:	owner-intelforum
Poster's Email:	owner-intelforum
Message Date:	2000-07-27 07:10:00 UTC

67 Spies and the Middle East Peace Talks -- rank: 486

... the time. But what I had in mind was not Pollard's guilt but the severity of his sentence, which you ... intel information with Israel at the time, and didn't Pollard >just tell Israel what we were committed to tell Israel ... agreement with Israel and it met every element of it. >POLLARD thought that there was intelligence not in the agreement that ... time, that the US government came down very hard on Pollard, as if we were out to increase rather than reduce ...

Poster's Name:	Anthony D' Amato
Poster's Email:	a-damato at northwestern.edu
Message Date:	2000-07-27 01:00:00 UTC

68 Spies and the Middle East Peace Talks -- rank: 331

... intel information with Israel at the time, and didn't Pollard just tell Israel what we were committed to tell Israel ... agreement with Israel and it met every element of it. POLLARD thought that there was intelligence not in the agreement that ...

Poster's Name:	HBP
Poster's Email:	BkCollector at home.com
Message Date:	2000-07-26 22:22:00 UTC

69 Spies and the Middle East Peace Talks -- rank: 331

... understand why Prof D'Amato >sings the tune of the Pollard apologists. Walker is but one example. How >about Ronald Pelton ... intel information with Israel at the time, and didn't Pollard just tell Israel what we were committed to tell Israel ...

Poster's Name:	kurt.jensen at dfait-maeci.gc.ca
Poster's Email:	kurt.jensen at dfait-maeci.gc.ca
Message Date:	2000-07-26 21:35:00 UTC

70 Spies and the Middle East Peace Talks -- rank: 331

... understand why Prof D'Amato >sings the tune of the Pollard apologists. Walker is but one example. How >about Ronald Pelton ... intel information with Israel at the time, and didn't Pollard just tell Israel what we were committed to tell Israel ...

Poster's Name:	Anthony D' Amato
Poster's Email:	a-damato at northwestern.edu
Message Date:	2000-07-26 20:36:00 UTC

71 Spies and the Middle East Peace Talks -- rank: 331

... at comlinks.com writes: > > << > US had no right > to give Pollard a life sentence when we gave spies for the USSR ... secrets to the USSR > of vastly more military importance than Pollard's stuff. Intelligence Forum (http://www.intelforum.org) is sponsored ...

Poster's Name:	Alan Simpson
Poster's Email:	news at comlinks.com
Message Date:	2000-07-26 20:06:00 UTC

72 Spies and the Middle East Peace Talks -- rank: 419

... at comlinks.com writes: << US had no right to give Pollard a life sentence when we gave spies for the USSR ... secrets to the USSR of vastly more military importance than Pollard's stuff. >> Not quite sure who said that, but the ... given life. The material he disclosed was largely straight Secret. Pollard was given life. The material he disclosed was largely Top ...

Poster's Name:	LevinMJ at aol.com
Poster's Email:	LevinMJ at aol.com
Message Date:	2000-07-26 19:28:00 UTC

73 Spies and the Middle East Peace Talks -- rank: 331

... wrote: ’Äú’Ķthe US had no right to give Pollard a life sentence when we gave spies for the USSR ... understand why Prof D'Amato sings the tune of the Pollard apologists. Walker is but one example. How about Ronald Pelton ...

Poster's Name:	LevinMJ at aol.com
Poster's Email:	LevinMJ at aol.com
Message Date:	2000-07-26 19:14:00 UTC

74 Spies and the Middle East Peace Talks -- rank: 486

... officer in Naval Special Warfare at the time of the Pollard affair--informed me that the life of at least one ... put in immediate jeopardy directly because of information that traitor Pollard provided to his Israeli handlers. > -----Original Message----- > From: Alan Simpson ... is for Naval Spies? > > US had no right > to give Pollard a life sentence when we gave spies for the USSR ... secrets to the USSR > of vastly more military importance than Pollard's stuff. > > OK I am biased. I do not believe ...

Poster's Name:	Bisher, James F.
Poster's Email:	james_f_bisher at md.northgrum.com
Message Date:	2000-07-26 12:28:00 UTC

75 Who we are, who we should be... -- rank: 209

... yellow stripes. No latitude for personal input. But consider, "Should Pollard be returned to the Israelis", "Should the NSA be disbanded ...

Poster's Name:	Alan Simpson
Poster's Email:	news at comlinks.com
Message Date:	2000-07-26 01:21:00 UTC